Every year, as Halloween creeps closer, I find myself obsessing over the spookiest treats I can possibly serve. I’m not just talking about pumpkin-shaped cookies—I mean desserts that make guests gasp before they even take a bite.
Eyeball truffles, bleeding cupcakes, ghostly pavlovas… the creepier, the better! There’s something oddly satisfying about making something that looks straight out of a horror movie but tastes absolutely divine.
Whether you’re hosting a haunted bash or just love playing mad scientist in the kitchen, I’ve gathered my favorite Halloween desserts that are almost too creepy to eat—almost. So if you’re brave enough, scroll on… and prepare to be deliciously disturbed.
These 15 spooky sweets might haunt your dreams—in the best way possible.
Black Velvet Cookies
These Black Velvet Cookies are spooky, soft, and stuffed full of a cheesecake center. The perfect Halloween cookies!
Check out this recipe
Halloween Pumpkin Cheesecake
This Halloween pumpkin cheesecake is a delicious, no-bake treat loaded with sweet flavors and decorated perfectly for the Halloween season.
Check out this recipe
Microwave Fudge with Candy Corn
This Microwave Fudge recipe is so easy to make! It only needs five ingredients and is the perfect treat for Halloween or Thanksgiving!
Check out this recipe
Halloween Dirt Cups
These Halloween Dirt Cups are frightfully fun! Layers of pudding, Oreo “dirt,” and cookie headstones make these the perfect spooky dessert!
Check out this recipe
Vegan Mummy Cupcakes will be a hit at your spooky Halloween bash.
These Vegan Mummy Cupcakes will be a hit at your spooky Halloween bash. They are fun to make, kid-friendly and completely adorable!
Check out this recipe
Easiest Ever Halloween Witch Cupcakes
Easiest Ever Halloween Witch Cupcakes, making these fun dessert treats is even easier thanks to this simple hack.
Check out this recipe
Halloween Brownies
Gooey Halloween Brownie recipe with colorful sprinkles and candy eyes that is one-bowl simple and has a fudgy texture. They can be frozen.
Check out this recipe
Nutter Butter Ghosts – The Short Order Cook
One of the best Halloween desserts – spooky Nutter Butter Ghosts This easy no-bake recipe is nutty, creamy, & fun for the fall holiday.
Check out this recipe
Witch Hat Cookies – The Short Order Cook
These cute witch hat cookies are an easy no-bake Halloween recipe. The festive treats are just 4 ingredients & fun to make
Check out this recipe
Halloween Chocolate Protein Puppy Chow (Muddy Buddies)
Bring this Halloween Chocolate Protein Puppy Chow to your next fall party! It’s chocolatey, sweet, crunchy, and full of classic Halloween candy like candy corn and mini Reese’s cups!
Check out this recipe
Halloween Bloody Bone Cupcakes Recipe
If you like all gory things, then you have to make this Halloween Bloody Bone Cupcakes recipe and add them to your creepy halloween treats.
Check out this recipe
Caramel Apple Cupcakes
Moist apple cupcakes with a hint of spice, topped with creamy caramel and crunchy peanuts. This weekend was my small town’s annual Fall Festival. Various businesses have booths with games, and crafters pitch their
Check out this recipe
Halloween Bundt Cake
This show-stopping Halloween Bundt Cake not only looks bloody, but also provides a memorable experience for your Halloween Party!
Check out this recipe
Halloween Whoopie Pies – Whisking Wolf
Rich, fudgy Halloween Whoopie Pies are bewitchingly black cakes with a fluffy layer of orange marshmallow filling in between.
Check out this recipe
Hocus Pocus Cookies – Whisking Wolf
These Hocus Pocus Cookies are soft, chewy sugar cookies swirled with spellbinding colors and are perfect treat for your Halloween party.
Check out this recipe
